A Review on The Black Star of Kingston by S. D. Smith 1
Ages 10 - 14,  Reviews

A Review on The Black Star of Kingston by S. D. Smith

  • S. D. Smith’s Green Ember series has caught the attention of many book lovers since the first one was published in 2014. 
  • The series in order of publication goes:

  •                                 The Green Ember (published Dec. 12, 2014)

                                   The Black Star of Kingston (published July 13, 2015)

                                   Ember Falls: The Green Ember Book II (published Sept. 11, 2016)

                                  The Last Archer: A Green Ember Story (published Dec. 12, 2017)

                                  Ember Rising: The Green Ember Book III (published Mar. 8, 2018)

  • This is not the order I am going to review them in however because The Black Star of Kingston was written as a prequel to The Green Ember, so that is where I am going to start.

TThe Black Star of Kingston

By S. D. Smith

Book 0.5 of The Green Ember Series

Age Range: 10 – 14+

Book attributes to be aware of: Violence.

The Black Star of Kingston by S. D. Smith is the prequel to the previously published book The Green Ember. It is the tale of what happened before the prologue in the Green Ember, in which a young rabbit, a Black Star (coal miner) gets together a company known as the Black Star company. Together with the king of Natalia and his men, the Black Star company sails across a river to some mountains beyond where they hope to find coal. They come upon coal, as well as some very eerie shrieking, which later turns out to be giant monster birds.

As the story unfolds we see more and more action. Beginning with nothing more than a big scare, by the end of the book we witness a gigantic battle between some hideous giant monster birds, and the much smaller Black Star Company. Many of the rabbits are wounded and killed, the rest flee for their lives. As we can determine from this small excerpt:

“He didn’t wait for them to find him. He drew his sword and leapt. Swinging wildly, he met the enemy aloft. His strokes, all but one met air. The one found a black breastplate. It’s owner clawed at Fleck as he fell. Two sets of talons tore at him, and then the birds veered off. He fell, spinning into the water. Battered and cut, he plunged below the surface… He saw several knots of fighting rabbits, their swords slicing the air. The deck was littered with the fallen…”

I would not recommend this book for small children, as it does get very violent, and ‘scary’ at times. This book is defiantly more suitable for children that are in the 10 – 14+ age range. That being said, some children that are under 10 years old are not as sensitive to the action, and don’t get frightened as easily. The same can be said in reverse, as some children that are 10 or older are more sensitive to lots of action and get frightened more easily. It is really up to the parents’ discretion.

The Black Star of Kingston is well written. It is very different than a lot of kid’s books, in the sense that it really does display the ugly without a lot nice to go with it.

There are times when there is happiness and carefree attitude shown, but it is scarce. This may be because it is the very beginning of the journey. We must remember that to make a good story there must be a problem. The characters must experience trial. It can’t all be lollipops and unicorns.

This story holds some very useful qualities. It can teach children that there is darkness in the world, but that there is good too. This story can also teach perseverance, loyalty, honesty, comradery, and above all hope.

The one quote that can be found throughout the entire book is an oath cried by the black star company before battle to the king:

“My place beside you, my blood for yours! Till the Green Ember rises, or the end of the world!”


Thank you for reading my review on The Black Star of Kingston.

I would enjoy hearing about your experience with the book, and what you thought of it. Feel free to write in the comment section below!

A Review on The Black Star of Kingston by S. D. Smith 2

A Review on The Black Star of Kingston by S. D. Smith 3

One Comment

  • Leslie

    Dear Maria,

    We just read your review. Thank you so much! We think it is a great series. You were wise to read/review that one first because it gets a little confusing when read in the true order like we did. We are not quite ten yet and didn’t find it too scary but agree that it is intense, it didn’t hold our younger siblings’ attention all the time because it is was too complicated for them and there are moments that definitely should be reserved for the age to 10-14+ age group. What an epic adventure! We look forward to your next review!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *